
Photo by Romain Dancre on Unsplash
Good debt pays for something that's likely to grow in value, or earn you more than the borrowing costs. A mortgage on a home that holds its value, or a student loan that leads to meaningfully higher lifetime pay, can fit this description.
Bad debt pays for things that lose value or get used up: a car loan, a credit card balance from everyday spending, buy-now-pay-later on things you wanted but didn't need. You pay interest, and nothing comes back to offset it.
The better question to ask
The good/bad labels are a handy shortcut, but they can mislead. A mortgage on a house bought at the wrong price, in the wrong market, can go badly. A student loan for a field with weak job prospects can become a burden rather than an investment.
So the more precise question is: does what you're borrowing for return more than the debt costs? If yes, the case for borrowing is stronger. If no, the debt is a cost with nothing on the other side of the scale. The return doesn't have to be purely financial, but you should be able to say what it is.
Why credit card debt is the worst kind
Credit cards are where most harmful debt lives. Interest rates of 20-30% APR are common, and at those rates interest compounds quickly.
A worked example, with round numbers: a $5,000 balance at 24% APR, paid down at a steady $150 a month with nothing new added, takes 56 months to clear, close to five years. The interest over that time comes to about $3,300, on top of the original $5,000. Paying only the minimum, which shrinks as the balance shrinks, can stretch the same balance past a decade and cost more in interest than the original amount.
It's also the easiest debt to pile up without noticing. Tap-to-pay and one-click checkout make borrowing feel like spending money you already have.
Using debt deliberately
Debt isn't bad in itself. Used on purpose, it lets you reach something now that would otherwise take years of saving. Four principles keep it on the right side of the line:
- Know the total cost, not just the monthly payment. A low monthly payment over a long term can cost far more overall.
- Borrow only for things with a return you can justify, financial or otherwise.
- Keep it manageable. Your total debt payments should still leave room to save and to cover surprises, which is what an emergency fund is for.
- Have a repayment plan before you borrow, not after.
A quick check before you borrow
| Question | Leans good | Leans bad |
|---|---|---|
| Will it grow in value or raise your income? | Likely | Unlikely |
| Is the interest rate low compared with that return? | Yes | No |
| Could you keep up payments if your income dipped? | Yes | Not sure |
| Do you know when it'll be paid off? | Yes | No |
Learn it properly
This is the subject of Finance Brain's Good Debt vs Bad Debt lesson, in the Personal Finance course. The same section goes on to how debt works in the first place and how to pay it off, and the lesson ends with a short quiz.
Finance Brain is educational content, not financial advice.