Caveats and Honest Limitations
The evidence for PE skill persistence, while real, comes with important qualifications:
Access is highly restricted: top-quartile PE funds — where the persistence evidence is strongest — are typically accessible only to large institutional investors (university endowments, sovereign wealth funds, large pension funds) and ultra-high-net-worth individuals. Retail investors accessing PE through listed vehicles or funds-of-funds face an additional layer of costs and typically do not access the top-tier managers.
Dispersion is enormous: unlike public equity where the difference between top-quartile and bottom-quartile active fund performance is measured in a few percentage points per year, PE return dispersion across managers is very wide. Bottom-quartile PE funds can meaningfully underperform public equity markets after fees. Getting manager selection wrong in PE is far more costly than in public markets.
The premium has compressed: as PE has grown from a niche asset class to a multi-trillion-dollar industry, the return premium over public equity has narrowed. Phalippou and Gottschalg (2009) found that once fees and risk adjustments were properly applied, many PE funds delivered less impressive returns than headline numbers suggested. Competition for deals has intensified, purchase price multiples have risen, and the easy operational improvements have been competed away.
Measurement challenges: PE returns are reported using internal rate of return (IRR), which is highly sensitive to the timing of cash flows and can be manipulated through the timing of distributions. Cross-fund comparisons are complex and require careful methodology.