The Mathematics
Consider two assets, each with an expected return of 10% per year and annual volatility (standard deviation) of 15%. If you hold them in equal weights:
If correlation = +1.0: portfolio volatility = 15% (no benefit — the assets move in lockstep). If correlation = 0.0: portfolio volatility ≈ 10.6% (a 29% reduction in volatility for the same expected return). If correlation = -1.0: portfolio volatility = 0% (the assets perfectly offset each other).
The 10.6% figure is not an approximation — it follows directly from the portfolio variance formula: √(0.5² × 15² + 0.5² × 15² + 2 × 0.5 × 0.5 × 15 × 15 × 0) = √(56.25 + 56.25) = √112.5 ≈ 10.6%.
The free lunch is the reduction from 15% to 10.6%: the investor keeps 100% of the expected return while shedding nearly 30% of the volatility, simply by combining two imperfectly correlated assets. No manager skill, no fee, no trade-off. The benefit comes purely from the mathematics of combining imperfectly correlated outcomes.