Why the Order of Returns Matters
Two investors can receive identical annual returns — the exact same percentages, in different orders — and end up with dramatically different wealth outcomes. This is not a paradox. It is a consequence of the interaction between the sequence of returns and the timing of withdrawals.
For an investor who is still accumulating wealth and making no withdrawals, sequence of returns does not matter: the geometric mean return is the same regardless of the order of annual figures. An investor contributing a fixed amount each year benefits somewhat from bad early years (because they buy more units cheaply) but is not harmed by the sequence in a fundamental way.
For an investor who is drawing down their portfolio — most critically, a retiree taking regular income — the sequence of returns is critical. A severe bear market in the early years of retirement forces the retiree to sell assets at depressed prices to fund living expenses. Those sold assets cannot participate in the subsequent recovery. The portfolio is permanently impaired.