Newsletter Trackers and the Hulbert Record

For over three decades, Mark Hulbert's Hulbert Financial Digest tracked the actual performance of hundreds of investment newsletter-based tactical models — systems that told subscribers when to be in the market and when to be out. The database, covering roughly 1980–2015, is one of the most comprehensive records of real-world tactical allocation attempts ever assembled.
The result was unambiguous: almost none of the tracked models outperformed a simple buy-and-hold strategy after costs over long periods. Some models outperformed for a year or two — enough to attract subscribers and generate credibility — but sustained outperformance was extremely rare and, when it occurred, was statistically indistinguishable from luck.
Hulbert's database also documented a consistent pattern: the models that attracted the most subscribers were those that had recently performed well, and subscribers typically arrived after the good performance rather than before it. By the time a tactical model had a large following, its best period was often behind it.