Finscape
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Evidence Against Tactical Allocation

For over three decades, Mark Hulbert's Hulbert Financial Digest tracked the actual performance of hundreds of investment newsletter-based tactical models — systems that told subscribers when to be in the market and when to be out. The database, covering roughly 1980–2015, is one of the most…

7 cards
Study this deck

Evidence Against Tactical Allocation

In this lesson · 4 sections
Step 4 of 4

The Cost Asymmetry

There is a fundamental asymmetry between market timing and passive holding. A passive investor makes no decisions and incurs minimal costs. A tactical allocator must be right on both the exit — selling before the decline — and the re-entry — buying before the recovery — to outperform. Each decision is difficult. Together, the probability of both being right is low. Charles Ellis captured this in his 1975 paper "The Loser's Game," arguing that for professional investors collectively, the attempt to outperform the market is not a winner's game — the aggregate costs of active management (research, trading, fees) are a tax on the market's return that, in aggregate, must be borne by active investors.

The evidence does not suggest that market timing is theoretically impossible. It suggests that it is practically very difficult, that costs erode most or all of any gross advantage, and that the average outcome of tactical allocation attempts is materially worse than passive holding.

Educational content only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Learn more

Quiz me on this
Hulbert Financial Digest
Save
Hulbert's verdict on timing newsletters
Save
"The Loser's Game" (1975)
Save
Buy and hold
Save