Finscape
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Guns and Butter

The "guns and butter" problem is one of economics' oldest examples: a government with finite resources must choose how much to allocate to military spending ("guns") versus civilian consumption ("butter"). Lyndon Johnson's refusal to make this choice during the Vietnam War era — trying to fund…

8 cards
Study this deck

Guns and Butter

In this lesson · 3 sections
Step 2 of 3

Johnson's Dilemma

a man wearing glasses
Photo by Fotos on Unsplash

By 1965, Lyndon Johnson faced a genuine political and economic dilemma. The Vietnam War, which he had inherited from Kennedy and escalated dramatically, was consuming increasing resources. Simultaneously, his Great Society programme — Medicare, Medicaid, the Civil Rights Act's economic provisions, the War on Poverty — represented the most ambitious domestic spending expansion since the New Deal.

Johnson's economic advisers, including Council of Economic Advisers chairman Gardner Ackley, warned him explicitly in December 1965 that simultaneously funding Vietnam and the Great Society without a tax increase would produce inflation. The economy was already at full employment; additional government demand would push against supply constraints and drive up prices.

Johnson was advised to choose: raise taxes (politically unpopular, especially while a war was being sold as limited and temporary), cut the Great Society (ideologically unacceptable), or cut military spending (operationally impossible without changing the war strategy). He chose a fourth option: do nothing, and hope the economy could absorb the pressure.