Which Factors Are Most Credible?
The most theoretically grounded factors are the original Fama-French ones: the market premium, the size premium, and the value premium. These have decades of out-of-sample evidence (including in international markets), theoretical rationale (risk-based or behavioural), and economic intuition behind them. Momentum is also very well documented internationally, though its lack of a clean risk-based explanation makes some researchers cautious.
The proliferation of niche factors — "quality at a reasonable price," "earnings revision momentum," "accruals anomaly" — is more suspect. Many have performed poorly once launched as investable products, consistent with the theory that publication and widespread trading arbitrages away the premium.