Market Risk
BRRRR is explicitly dependent on the post-refurbishment property value meeting or exceeding projections. If local property prices fall between purchase and refinance — or if the market simply does not respond to refurbishment as expected — the capital recycling mechanism fails.
Investors who executed BRRRR in 2006–2007, expecting to refinance at higher values, were instead refinancing into a market where values had fallen below purchase prices. The strategy that was supposed to recycle capital instead left investors unable to remortgage at all in some cases.