Clarifying the Finding
The BHB result is widely cited but also widely misunderstood. The study measured variability — how closely a portfolio's return fluctuations track a passive benchmark. It did not conclude that asset allocation determines 93.6% of absolute wealth accumulated over a lifetime. Roger Ibbotson and Paul Kaplan addressed this in their 2000 paper. Their analysis found that asset allocation explains roughly 90% of the variability of returns over time, and approximately 100% of the absolute return level — because in aggregate, all investors collectively own the market, so the market return is what they earn before costs.
A further nuance: the BHB study examined large institutional funds, which had broadly similar asset allocations and were all professionally managed. In that context, small differences in allocation accounted for nearly all observable differences in performance. For individual investors, the result is even more powerful: most private investors do not have 91 competing funds to benchmark against — they just need their own allocation to be right.