A Decision Framework
A useful framework for evaluating active versus passive in any specific context: (1) Is this market demonstrably less efficient, based on structural reasons rather than hope? (2) Is there specific, verifiable evidence of persistent skill from this particular manager, beyond recent returns? (3) After accounting for higher fees, trading costs, tax drag, and the opportunity cost of not using the passive alternative — is the expected alpha still positive? In most cases, applying this framework honestly leads back to low-cost index funds as the default.