When Bond Markets Lose Confidence

The bond market's willingness to fund war at affordable rates is not guaranteed. It depends on lenders' belief that the state will repay. When that belief collapses, borrowing costs rise sharply, forcing states toward more inflationary financing or outright default.
France in the 18th century illustrates the failure mode. The French monarchy's history of partial defaults — reducing interest rates unilaterally, restructuring debt without creditor consent — meant French borrowing costs consistently exceeded English ones. By the 1780s, approximately half of French government expenditure went to debt service. The fiscal crisis this created was a direct cause of the conditions that led to the Revolution of 1789. The inability to borrow cheaply was not merely a financial inconvenience; it was a factor in the collapse of the regime.
The same dynamic operates in modern sovereign debt crises. A government that appears likely to default — or to inflate away its debt — will find bond buyers demanding higher yields to compensate for the risk. Higher yields increase debt service costs, worsening the fiscal position, potentially triggering a self-reinforcing spiral. The bond market's judgment on government solvency is swift and remorseless in a way that direct taxation never is.