The Fund Selection Problem
Academic evidence confirms what intuition suggests. Friesen and Sapp (2007) found that mutual fund investors systematically buy after periods of strong performance and sell after periods of weak performance. Funds with the highest recent inflows subsequently underperform funds with the lowest inflows. Buying the top-performing fund of the past three years is a consistently poor strategy — not because past performance has no information content, but because it is the wrong kind: high recent returns often mean lower future returns (mean reversion), not higher.