We Think We're Better Than We Are
Overconfidence is one of the most pervasive and well-documented biases in human psychology. People systematically overestimate their own abilities, the accuracy of their knowledge, and their ability to predict the future.
In one classic study, 93% of American drivers rated themselves as above average — a statistical impossibility. In financial forecasting experiments, analysts were asked to provide 90% confidence intervals for their predictions — ranges within which they were 90% sure the true answer would fall. The true answer fell outside their ranges far more often than 10% of the time. They were far more confident than they were accurate.
Overconfidence manifests in three distinct forms: overplacement (believing you are better than others), overestimation (believing you will perform better than you actually do), and overprecision (believing your predictions are more accurate than they are). In financial contexts, all three appear.