The Normal Distribution Assumption
The Sharpe ratio's theoretical foundations assume that portfolio returns are normally distributed — that the bell curve adequately describes how returns are spread around their mean. In practice, financial returns are not normally distributed. They exhibit two key departures:
First, fat tails: extreme events (very large gains or very large losses) occur far more frequently than the normal distribution predicts. A move of three standard deviations should occur about 0.3% of the time under normality; in practice, it occurs far more often in financial markets.
Second, negative skewness: large losses occur more often than large gains of the same magnitude. Financial markets crash faster than they rise; the distribution of returns is asymmetric.
A strategy that earns steady small gains while occasionally suffering catastrophic losses can exhibit exactly this profile: low standard deviation in normal times (producing a high Sharpe ratio), punctuated by rare but devastating drawdowns that the Sharpe ratio fails to capture. Nassim Taleb has repeatedly highlighted this pattern — "picking up nickels in front of a steamroller" — as a systematic failure mode of Sharpe ratio-based evaluation.