The Caveat: Indicators as Discipline, Not Prediction

The critical limitation of technical indicators is well established in academic finance. Research consistently finds that no single indicator or combination of indicators generates statistically significant excess returns on a standalone basis after accounting for transaction costs and data-mining biases.
What indicators can do is impose discipline: providing structured criteria for entries, exits, and risk management that prevent purely emotional decision-making. A trader who only buys when RSI is below 40 and sells when it exceeds 70 is following a rule — and rules, even imperfect ones, tend to produce more consistent outcomes than impulse-driven decisions. This is the most defensible use of technical tools for most investors.