The Burden of Proof Has Shifted
If markets are even semi-strong efficient, then analysing publicly available information to find mispriced securities is — in aggregate — a zero-sum game before costs and a negative-sum game after them. This does not mean every active manager underperforms every year. It means that the burden of proof lies squarely with active strategies to demonstrate genuine, persistent alpha after fees.
The evidence has largely failed to discharge that burden. Study after study, across geographies, time periods, and asset classes, shows that most active managers underperform their passive benchmark over horizons of ten years or more. The minority who do outperform are not reliably identifiable in advance.