The Joint Hypothesis Problem
A subtle technical point matters here. Any test of market efficiency is simultaneously a test of the asset pricing model used as the benchmark. If a strategy appears to generate alpha relative to the CAPM, this might reflect genuine inefficiency — or it might mean the CAPM is an incomplete model of risk (which Fama himself later demonstrated with his multi-factor models). Anomalies can persist in the literature for years before researchers establish whether they reflect true inefficiency or simply missing risk factors.