The 2008 Crisis and Rating Agency Criticism

The 2007–2008 financial crisis produced a severe indictment of the rating agencies. Vast quantities of structured credit products — in particular collateralised debt obligations (CDOs) backed by US subprime mortgages — were assigned AAA ratings, the highest available. When the underlying mortgages began defaulting, many of these AAA-rated instruments became nearly worthless almost overnight.
The criticism focused on two structural problems:
- The issuer-pays model: rating agencies are paid by the issuers whose bonds they rate, creating a conflict of interest. Issuers could shop for favourable ratings, and agencies had commercial incentives to maintain relationships with large, frequent issuers.
- Model failures: the statistical models used to rate structured products assumed that US house prices could not fall simultaneously across all geographies — an assumption that proved catastrophically wrong.
Post-2008 reforms included the Dodd-Frank Act provisions requiring greater transparency and accountability from rating agencies, though the fundamental issuer-pays conflict of interest has never been fully resolved.