Criticisms and Limitations
Target-date funds have genuine limitations. The one-size-fits-all design ignores individual circumstances that should affect the appropriate allocation. An investor with a generous defined benefit pension, significant housing equity, or plans to work part-time in retirement has very different needs from someone entirely reliant on their investment portfolio. The same 2050 fund is held by both.
Different providers use substantially different glide paths without clear consensus on which is best. An investor who does not understand this may believe all 2050 funds are equivalent — they are not.
Investors who hold other assets alongside a target-date fund — additional equity funds, individual stocks, property — may inadvertently over- or under-diversify without realising it. The target-date fund is designed to be a complete portfolio, and holding it alongside other investments requires careful thought about the combined allocation.