Keynes' Argument
Keynes made three interconnected arguments:
-
Transfer problem: For Germany to pay reparations, it needed to earn foreign exchange through exports. But the Allies simultaneously wanted reparations and protection of their own industries from German exports. Germany could not pay without exporting; the Allies would not accept German exports. The arithmetic did not work.
-
Productive capacity: The reparations figure was multiples of what the German economy could sustainably transfer to foreign creditors. Demanding payments that exceed what a debtor can produce is not policy; it is fantasy.
-
Political consequences: Imposing economically impossible terms on a population would produce resentment and political instability. "Carthaginian peace" — crushing a defeated enemy rather than integrating it — creates the conditions for renewed conflict.