The CEO Halo Effect
Psychologist Phil Rosenzweig documented a specific manifestation of narrative bias in business in The Halo Effect (2007). When a company performs well, observers construct a coherent narrative in which the CEO is visionary, the culture is excellent, and the strategy is brilliant. When the same company later underperforms, the narrative reverses: the CEO was arrogant, the culture was complacent, the strategy was flawed.
The underlying facts often haven't changed — only the outcome, which drives the narrative. This halo-and-horn effect has direct implications for how investors assess management quality: the narrative about a CEO is often just the share price performance translated into story form.