Roll Yield: The Hidden Return Driver
Most investors in commodity futures never take delivery of the physical commodity. Instead, they roll their positions forward: before the contract expires, they sell the expiring contract and buy a new contract with a later delivery date.
The roll yield captures the gain or loss from this rolling process. In a backwardated market, futures prices are below spot prices, so rolling forward means selling an expiring contract at a relatively high price and buying a cheaper future-dated contract. This generates a positive roll yield — a return in addition to any spot price movement.
In a contango market, the opposite holds. Rolling forward means selling a low-priced expiring contract and buying a more expensive future-dated contract — a negative roll yield that erodes returns even if spot prices are unchanged. The 2004-2012 period saw persistent contango in oil markets, causing commodity index investors to significantly underperform the spot oil price.
Roll yield can be a larger driver of long-run returns from commodity futures than spot price appreciation — a point often missed by investors who focus only on commodity price charts.