The Revisionist Debate
Hamilton's silver-inflation thesis has been challenged by later historians. Some argue that population growth — European population roughly doubled between 1400 and 1600 — was as important a driver of price increases as monetary expansion, increasing demand for food and pushing agricultural prices up independently of silver. Others argue that the correlation between silver imports and prices is less clean than Hamilton presented.
The current historical consensus is that both factors contributed: silver expanded the money supply while population growth increased real demand. The Price Revolution illustrates that causation in historical price episodes is rarely monocausal — but the monetary channel was real and significant.