Why Scarcity Matters (and the Debate)

The investment thesis for Bitcoin rests heavily on scarcity. The argument: unlike fiat currencies (where central banks can expand the money supply), Bitcoin's supply is fixed and verifiable. If demand grows while supply is fixed, price must rise. Saifedean Ammous, in The Bitcoin Standard (2018), developed the economic case for Bitcoin as "hard money" superior to gold or fiat.
The counter-argument: scarcity alone does not create value. Many things are scarce and worthless. Bitcoin's value depends on continued adoption and belief in its utility or store-of-value properties — neither of which is guaranteed. The fixed supply makes Bitcoin deflationary, which may discourage spending (why spend an appreciating asset?) and concentrate wealth in early holders.