BCOM vs GSCI: Different Exposures, Different Returns
Although both indices track commodity futures, their returns can diverge dramatically over short and medium time periods — entirely because of the difference in composition weights.
During the 2014-2016 oil price collapse, the GSCI fell approximately 50% while BCOM fell around 30% — the same commodity markets, but a dramatically different investor experience. Conversely, during the 2021-2022 energy price spike, the GSCI's heavy energy weighting produced substantially higher returns than BCOM. An investor choosing between the two is not choosing between "more" and "less" commodity exposure — they are choosing different commodity risk profiles.