Survivorship Bias: Making the Truth Worse
The headline underperformance numbers, already damning, actually understate the problem due to survivorship bias. Investment funds that perform poorly tend to be closed — merged into better-performing siblings, liquidated, or simply shut down. If only surviving funds are included in the analysis, the track record looks better than it was for the full cohort of investors who experienced both the good and bad funds.
SPIVA's methodology explicitly corrects for this. The scorecard tracks all funds that were active at the start of the measurement period, including those subsequently closed. The result is that when survivorship bias is properly accounted for, the underperformance rate is even higher than naive comparisons would suggest. Investors evaluating past performance typically see only survivors — creating a systematically misleading picture.