Where Active Fares Better

The SPIVA data does show some categories where active management performs relatively better — though "better" is relative. Some actively managed intermediate bond and alternatives categories show lower underperformance rates than equity categories. The explanation is likely structural: bond markets include many forced or constrained buyers (pension funds required to hold certain ratings, central banks pursuing policy goals) that may create pricing inefficiencies a skilled active manager can exploit. But even in these categories, the majority of active funds still underperform over long periods.