Why the Distinction Matters — and Its Limits

The good/bad framework is a useful mental shortcut, but it has limits. A mortgage on a property at the wrong price or in the wrong market can turn out badly. A student loan in a field with poor employment outcomes can become a burden, not an investment.
The more precise question is: Does the expected return on what I'm borrowing for exceed the cost of the debt? If yes, the case for borrowing is stronger. If no, the debt is a liability with no compensating upside.