The Decision That Matters Most

Most investors spend their time trying to select the best individual stocks or time the market. Research suggests that neither activity is the primary driver of long-term portfolio performance. What matters far more is asset allocation: the decision about how to divide a portfolio among broad asset categories — equities, bonds, real assets, cash.
The evidence for this claim comes from one of the most cited studies in investment finance: Gary Brinson, L. Randolph Hood, and Gilbert Beebower's 1986 paper, "Determinants of Portfolio Performance," published in the Financial Analysts Journal. Analysing 91 large US pension funds over a ten-year period, they concluded that approximately 93.6% of the variability in quarterly returns across portfolios was explained by their asset allocation policy — not by market timing or security selection, which together explained only a small residual fraction.
The finding was influential and provocative. It implied that the majority of what investors typically focus on — which specific shares to buy — is largely noise relative to the more fundamental question of what percentage of the portfolio is in equities versus bonds versus cash.