Why Progressivity Is Contested
A progressive tax system — one where higher incomes face higher marginal rates — rests on several rationales. The most intuitive is "ability to pay": a dollar is worth less in marginal utility to someone with a million of them than to someone with very few, so taxing a higher fraction of high incomes imposes a lower real burden. A related argument holds that high earners benefit disproportionately from the public goods and institutions — infrastructure, courts, property rights, rule of law — that allow wealth to accumulate and be protected in the first place.
The academic case for high top marginal rates received prominent expression in a 2011 paper by economists Peter Diamond and Emmanuel Saez in the Journal of Economic Perspectives. Drawing on estimates of how responsive high earners' taxable income is to changes in the top rate — a measure called the elasticity of taxable income — they argued that the revenue-maximizing top marginal rate could be 70% or higher. Their analysis influenced a wave of policy debate about top-rate increases in the 2010s and early 2020s.
Critics of steep progressivity argue that high marginal rates distort economic behavior in harmful ways: discouraging work effort at the top of the income distribution, reducing investment and entrepreneurial risk-taking, and encouraging high earners to shift income into forms that are taxed more lightly or deferred into the future. Some critics also argue that focusing solely on the federal income tax understates the real burden on middle-income earners, who also pay payroll taxes of up to 15.3% on earned income (split between employer and employee) — a flat tax with no brackets that falls most heavily, as a share of income, on wage earners in the middle.