Share Buybacks: The Rise of the Alternative Return Mechanism

From the 1980s onward, and especially in the United States, share buybacks (or share repurchases) became the primary method by which large public companies returned capital to shareholders. A buyback reduces the number of shares outstanding, which — if the company's total value remains constant — increases earnings per share and the ownership percentage of remaining shareholders.
Buybacks have structural advantages over dividends: they are flexible (a company can buy back shares in good years and pause in bad years without the market interpreting it as a distress signal), they may be more tax-efficient in jurisdictions where capital gains are taxed more favourably than dividend income, and they allow investors to choose whether to participate by tendering their shares.
Critics argue that buybacks are often poorly timed — companies buying back stock at elevated prices rather than during weakness — and that they are used to offset executive stock option dilution rather than to genuinely return value. The empirical evidence on buyback timing is mixed: aggregate US corporate buyback activity has historically been procyclical (high during booms, low during recessions).