The Problem with Raw Return Comparisons
Suppose Fund A returned 18% last year and Fund B returned 12%. Which was the better investment? The answer is: it depends entirely on how much risk each fund took to achieve those returns.
Fund A may have achieved its 18% by concentrating heavily in a handful of volatile small-cap stocks. In a different year, the same strategy might return -30%. Fund B, with its steadier 12%, may have done so with half the volatility — meaning it would also fall far less in a bad year. An investor who compares only the headline returns, and picks Fund A as the better performer, is missing the point entirely.
This is the central problem with raw return figures: they contain no information about the risk taken to earn them. Risk-adjusted returns solve this by incorporating a measure of risk into the evaluation.