Planning Implications
The step-up in basis creates a simple but powerful planning rule for investors with highly appreciated positions: do not sell if you can avoid it. Instead, hold appreciated assets until death, borrow against them if cash is needed (loans are not taxable events), and donate them to charity rather than selling.
Donors who contribute appreciated securities directly to charity — or to a Donor-Advised Fund — avoid the capital gains tax entirely and deduct the full fair market value of the securities. This makes donating appreciated securities significantly more efficient than donating cash: donating $10,000 of stock with a $2,000 basis saves both the $1,200–$1,900 in capital gains tax that would have been owed on a sale and generates the same charitable deduction as a $10,000 cash gift.
Critics argue the step-up is one of the most regressive provisions in the tax code because it disproportionately benefits the wealthiest estates — ordinary wage earners accumulate little in the way of highly appreciated taxable assets relative to business owners, investors, and real estate holders. It has survived repeated legislative challenges, including proposals by Presidents Obama and Biden to tax gains at death or eliminate the step-up entirely.
The persistence of the step-up means that the optimal hold-versus-sell decision for appreciated assets often turns on life expectancy and estate planning considerations, not just investment merits. A financial plan that ignores the step-up can lead to premature realisation of gains that would have been tax-free had the investor simply waited.