The Edict's Failure

The edict failed immediately and comprehensively. Sellers withdrew goods from open markets rather than sell at prices below their cost of replacement. Shortages replaced inflation: goods disappeared from markets in cities where the edict was enforced. Trade routes shifted away from strictly policed areas. The historian Lactantius, writing shortly after, described the edict producing such severe shortages that it was eventually abandoned — though he wrote from a hostile perspective.
The economic reason for failure was not complex: the edict set prices below market-clearing levels for many goods. When prices are prevented from rising to reflect monetary expansion, sellers either exit the market or find informal channels. The price control succeeded only in converting price inflation (goods became more expensive) into quantity suppression (goods became unavailable).