Fat Tails in Practice

Fat tails (formally: leptokurtosis) means that extreme events occur far more often than the normal distribution predicts. The tails of the actual return distribution are "fatter" than the bell curve — there is more probability mass far from the mean in both directions.
The 2008 financial crisis provided a stark demonstration. Collateralised debt obligations, mortgage-backed securities, and many equity markets experienced moves that their risk models — calibrated to the normal distribution — assigned probabilities of occurring once in tens of thousands of years. Multiple such events occurred within weeks of one another in September and October 2008. The models were not wrong about the mathematics; they were wrong about the distribution.
David Li's Gaussian copula model, used to price CDOs, assumed normally distributed default correlations. When default correlations spiked during the crisis, the model's predictions failed catastrophically. This failure played a material role in the 2008 financial crisis, making it arguably the most consequential mathematical modelling error in financial history.