Why the Arithmetic Mean Overstates What You Actually Earn

The arithmetic mean can be deeply misleading as a guide to investor experience. Consider an extreme example: a fund that returns +50% in year one and -50% in year two. The arithmetic mean is 0%. But an investor who starts with £1,000 ends with £750. They have lost 25% of their capital despite a "zero" average return.
This gap — between the arithmetic mean and the geometric mean — is not a quirk of extreme examples. It occurs whenever there is any variability in returns, and it grows with volatility. The geometric mean will always be less than or equal to the arithmetic mean; they are equal only when returns are identical every period.
The relationship between the two is approximately: geometric mean ≈ arithmetic mean − (variance / 2). Variance is the square of standard deviation, so a fund with 20% annual volatility loses roughly 2% per year to this effect compared to its arithmetic mean. This is known as volatility drag, or variance drain.