A Mathematical Proof, Not an Empirical Claim
Most arguments about investing involve uncertain empirical claims — past performance, future market conditions, the skill of a particular manager. William Sharpe's 1991 paper "The Arithmetic of Active Management," published in the Financial Analysts Journal, was different. It made the case for passive investing using pure accounting logic, with no reliance on data or assumptions about skill.
The argument is elegant and inescapable: all investors collectively own the entire market. If some investors own more of a stock than the market weight, others must own less. The total of all positions, at any moment, adds up exactly to the market. This is a simple accounting identity.