The Implication Is Guaranteed, Not Probabilistic
Sharpe was explicit about the significance of this framing. His conclusion is not a forecast — it is a guaranteed outcome, as certain as arithmetic. The average active investor must underperform the average passive investor after costs. This is true regardless of how smart active managers are, regardless of market conditions, and regardless of time period.
This does not mean no active manager can outperform — some can and do. It means that for every active manager who beats the market, there must be other active investors who underperform by an equivalent amount. The winners are offset by losers, and costs come out of the entire active pool.