Efficiency Is Not Uniform
The case for passive investing is strongest where markets are most efficient. But efficiency is not a binary property — it varies across markets, asset classes, and time periods. Understanding where passive makes the most sense requires understanding what drives market efficiency in the first place.
Market efficiency depends on the number and quality of participants actively analysing a security. When thousands of well-resourced professional analysts are competing to identify mispricing in the same securities, the marginal value of additional analysis rapidly approaches zero. In such a market, the costs of active management are most punishing and the probability of finding a genuine edge is lowest.