The Case Is Strongest in US Large-Cap Equities
US large-cap equities represent the most compelling case for passive investing. The S&P 500's constituent companies are covered by more analysts, with more publicly available data and more sophisticated modelling tools, than any other market on earth. Price-relevant information is incorporated almost instantaneously. The residual opportunities for analysis-based alpha — if they exist at all — are tiny compared to the costs of the analysts required to find them.
SPIVA data confirms this: roughly 88-92% of active US large-cap equity funds underperform the S&P 500 over 15-year periods. For most investors, the default in this asset class should emphatically be passive.