Two Approaches to Rebalancing
Once an investor accepts that portfolios drift and that drift should be corrected, a practical question arises: how often, and by what trigger? There are two main approaches.
Calendar-based rebalancing sets a schedule: quarterly, semi-annually, or annually. On the scheduled date, the investor checks the portfolio weights and trades back toward the target allocation regardless of how much or how little drift has occurred. The advantage is simplicity and regularity. The disadvantage is that the calendar is arbitrary — a portfolio that has barely drifted may be traded unnecessarily, incurring costs, while a portfolio that drifts dramatically between dates may go uncorrected for too long.
Threshold-based rebalancing, sometimes called opportunistic rebalancing, triggers a rebalance only when an asset class deviates beyond a specified tolerance band — for example, if any asset class moves more than 5 percentage points from its target. A 60% equity target has a band of 55–65%; only if equities fall outside that range does rebalancing occur. Research by Glen Daryanani (2008) in the Journal of Financial Planning found that threshold-based rebalancing generally delivers better outcomes than calendar rebalancing because it responds to actual portfolio needs rather than arbitrary dates.
A hybrid approach combines both: check the portfolio on a regular schedule, but only trade if thresholds have been breached. This is the approach recommended by Vanguard Research in its 2015 paper "Best Practices for Portfolio Rebalancing."