The Mechanical Logic
Rebalancing has a structural property that is easy to state but psychologically difficult to act on: it automatically forces buying of underperforming assets and selling of outperforming ones. This is the classic "buy low, sell high" principle — achieved not through predictive skill but through the simple discipline of maintaining a fixed target allocation.
When equities fall sharply, a rebalancing investor sells bonds (which have held their value or risen) and buys equities (which are now cheaper). When equities surge, the opposite occurs: bonds are purchased with the proceeds of equity sales. The investor is not making a prediction about future prices. They are simply correcting the portfolio back to its intended weights. The buy-low, sell-high behaviour is the automatic consequence of that correction.
This is the key insight: rebalancing does not require market timing ability. It requires only the discipline to execute trades that feel deeply uncomfortable in the moment — buying equities during a crash, selling them during a euphoric rally.