During a Market Crash
The behavioural challenge of rebalancing is most severe during market crashes. In early 2009, as equity markets fell 50% from their 2007 peak, the correct rebalancing action for any investor with an equity allocation was to buy more equities at depressed prices. Most investors did the opposite — they reduced equity exposure or fled to cash, locking in losses.
An investor following a mechanical rebalancing schedule would have bought equities in 2009 and sold some of those positions as markets recovered through 2010–2013. The result would have been meaningfully better long-run performance than the average investor achieved through emotion-driven trading.
The same dynamic played out in March 2020 during the COVID-19 market crash. Equities fell approximately 35% in five weeks. A disciplined rebalancer bought. By the end of 2020, equity markets had fully recovered and then some. The investors who sold in panic and re-entered later captured only part of the recovery.