What the Academic Evidence Shows
Academic studies of rebalancing consistently find a nuanced result. Compared to a buy-and-hold portfolio that is never rebalanced, a rebalanced portfolio tends to produce slightly lower long-run absolute returns. This is because rebalancing trims the winners and supports the losers — in a long bull market for equities, trimming equities sacrifices some upside.
However, rebalancing significantly reduces volatility and maximum drawdown — the worst peak-to-trough decline the investor experiences. For most investors, this trade-off is favourable: modestly lower returns in exchange for a smoother ride and avoidance of catastrophic portfolio outcomes.
More importantly, the academic comparison is to a hypothetical investor who holds the drifted portfolio and never panics. Real investors do panic. The true comparison should be between a rebalanced portfolio and the actual outcomes of unmanaged portfolios, where drift leads to increased risk that eventually triggers panic selling at the worst possible moment.