Distinguishing Luck from Skill
If active management is negative-sum in aggregate, individual outperformers exist. How many of these are due to genuine skill versus good fortune?
Michael Mauboussin, in his book The Success Equation (2012), provides a rigorous framework for separating luck and skill. He argues that the appropriate test of skill is the ability to predict one's future performance from past performance. In activities dominated by skill (chess, surgery), past performance is highly predictive. In activities dominated by luck (lottery outcomes), it is not.
Studies of mutual fund performance persistence — including a 2010 paper by Eugene Fama and Kenneth French ("Luck versus Skill in the Cross-Section of Mutual Fund Returns") — found very limited evidence of genuine skill among active fund managers. Past outperformance, net of fees, has low predictive power for future outperformance. The top-quartile funds of one decade are not significantly more likely to be top-quartile in the next than chance would predict.