The Cost Compounding Problem
Even if a manager adds modest genuine skill — say, 0.5% annual outperformance before fees — the cost structure of active management typically consumes this and more. Active equity funds in the UK and US typically charge 0.6–1.2% annually. The average investor in active funds, after fees, captures less of the market return than a passive investor with a 0.05% expense ratio.
Over 30 years, the fee differential alone, compounded, represents a substantial fraction of terminal portfolio value. Sharpe's arithmetic ensures that most investors would have been better off in a low-cost index fund.