When Active Management May Add Value
The case against active management is strongest in large-cap developed market equities — the most efficiently priced segment of global markets, with thousands of analysts competing for every mispricing. The case is somewhat weaker in small-cap, emerging market, or less liquid segments where information is less efficiently processed and skilled analysts may genuinely identify persistent mispricings.
There are also strategies (distressed debt, certain arbitrage approaches, private credit) where systematic information advantages may be more durable. The appropriate conclusion is not that skill is impossible, but that it is rare, hard to identify in advance, and frequently consumed by costs.