Earlier Evidence: Gruber's Puzzle
Martin Gruber's 1996 paper "Another Puzzle: The Growth in Actively Managed Mutual Funds" asked a related question: if active funds underperform on average, why do investors continue to use them? He dubbed this the "smart money" hypothesis — perhaps some sophisticated investors can identify skilled managers. His evidence for this was weak at the time and has not strengthened since. The puzzle he identified — rational investor behaviour in the face of poor expected outcomes — remains a live question in behavioural finance.