Finscape
Sign in
← Back to decks
Sign in to save your progress.Sign in

Persistence of Manager Performance

Before allocating capital to an active fund, investors invariably look at its track record. This behaviour is almost universal — retail investors, financial advisers, and sophisticated institutions all give significant weight to past returns. The implicit assumption is that a manager who has…

8 cards
Study this deck

Persistence of Manager Performance

In this lesson · 5 sections
Step 4 of 5

The Intuitive Appeal and Its Failure

The intuitive appeal of past performance is understandable. In most fields, demonstrated competence predicts future competence. A surgeon with a strong track record, a lawyer who wins cases, an engineer who builds reliable structures — past performance is informative. Investment management appears similar on the surface. But there are critical differences: the signal-to-noise ratio in investment returns is extremely low, the time periods required to distinguish skill from luck are decades long (not years), and the competitive environment changes continuously.

A fund manager who outperformed over five years may have benefited from a style tailwind (value was in favour, or growth was in favour), sector concentration (technology in the 1990s, energy in the 2000s), or pure statistical luck. Distinguishing genuine alpha — consistent outperformance across different market environments — from these noise sources requires far more data than is typically available.