The Intuitive Appeal and Its Failure
The intuitive appeal of past performance is understandable. In most fields, demonstrated competence predicts future competence. A surgeon with a strong track record, a lawyer who wins cases, an engineer who builds reliable structures — past performance is informative. Investment management appears similar on the surface. But there are critical differences: the signal-to-noise ratio in investment returns is extremely low, the time periods required to distinguish skill from luck are decades long (not years), and the competitive environment changes continuously.
A fund manager who outperformed over five years may have benefited from a style tailwind (value was in favour, or growth was in favour), sector concentration (technology in the 1990s, energy in the 2000s), or pure statistical luck. Distinguishing genuine alpha — consistent outperformance across different market environments — from these noise sources requires far more data than is typically available.